Category Archives: Future of news

More for journalism grads 2011: Think about NOT waiting

Robert Krulwich, to Berkeley Journalism School Class of 2011… excerpts below, but just click that link and read the whole thing.

I’ve tried, but excerpts just don’t do this one justice. Peabody Award winner Krulwich starts with a nice summary of the “little satisfactions” of journalism; later, he tells some “old days” stories for contrast; eventually, he does a better job than most at pointing more than one way toward the future. By the end, it’s a love story.

Some excerpts, anyway:

So how do you taste more of what you tasted here, which (if I can presume) includes the thrill of occasionally writing a good sentence, of asking exactly the right question at the right moment, of making two pieces of tape fit perfectly together, of getting to meet new people, go new places, see things unfold… these little satisfactions of journalism… how can you have more of that?

———-

I am here to tell you, that you are stepping into a world that is riper, more pregnant with newness, new ideas, new beats, new opportunities than most generations of journalists before you. You are lucky to be you, very lucky, though you may not be feeling it at the moment.

———-

Journalism doesn’t have to be your first love… or your only love.  You can come to it in desperation, because you can’t think of anything better to do with your life, that it’s this or the abyss.But once you get going… it helps if you love it…

What you love can differ, but the love, once it comes, that feeling of waking up with a kind of eagerness, a crazy momentum that pushes you into your day, an excitement you realize you don’t ever want to go way… that’s important.

———-

When you talk or write or film, you work with the music inside you, the music that formed you. Different generations have different musics in them, so whatever they do, it’s going to come out differently and it will speak in beats of their own generation.The people in charge, of course, don’t want to change. They like the music they’ve got. To the newcomers, they say, “Wait your turn”.

But in a world like this… rampant with new technologies, and new ways to do things, the newcomers… that means you… you here today, you have to trust your music… It’s how you talk to people your age, your generation. This is how we change.

———-

Think about entrepeneuring. Think about NOT waiting for a company to call you up. Think about not giving your heart to a bunch of adults you don’t know. Think about horizontal loyalty. Think about turning to people you already know, who are your friends, or friends of their friends and making something that makes sense to you together, that is as beautiful or as true as you can make it.

DO go read the whole thing. If Berkeley puts the audio of this speech online, I’d recommend downloading into an iPod, setting it to “loop,” and playing it as you go to sleep… Let it work its way into your dreams.

New tools and new rules

The last week of the semester is a great time for an inspirational speech. Rather than give one myself, I’ve found one in text and video for my “basic newswriting” students, whose semester experiences have ranged from AP Stylebook drills to reading about tornado damage in their own backyard.

During our Communication Week, they heard local reporters talk about their lives — from Beth Macy covering a cholera epidemic in Haiti and Ralph Berrier interviewing pioneers of bluegrass music, to  recent grad Justin Ward launching his career into regional TV news.

Maybe they don’t need another inspirational speech. But we’ve heard enough doom-and-gloom about the newspaper business (and I do teach a newspaper style of writing). Perhaps this will help.

Here… Listen to Eric Newton, senior adviser to the president at the Knight Foundation, speaking at the College of Journalism and Mass Communication of the University of Nebraska, whose new dean came from Knight, which is using a newspaper-generated bankroll to fund innovative journalism projects. His real message starts about a dozen paragraphs into the speech…

All you need to do is plug into the stream and you see journalism and mass communication developments coming faster and more forcefully than ever. This is the dawn of a new age in communication, the digital age, and it is even richer with invention than the dawn of the industrial age.

New tools are being invented at a mind-boggling pace. Instead of the telegraph, the telephone and the light bulb, we’re talking about microchips, laptops, smart phones, tablets. We’re talking about companies like Google, YouTube, Facebook and Twitter: from digital zero to number one in the market, nearly overnight.

As the legendary journalist Hodding Carter III once said, “This is the most exciting time ever to be a journalist – if you are not in search of the past.” The same I would say applies to being any kind of communicator – advertising, public relations, you name it.

That’s what’s exciting. The students of today actually are going to create the journalism and mass communication of tomorrow….

His “New tools create new rules” discussion, alluded to in my headline, comes later. Students should read the whole speech to find out just what he means.

Here’s the full text
and an MP4 video

Why, Baby, Why? Shaky link to history at USAToday.com

Don’t let your robot-editor hurt your credibility

End of summer ‘lull’ opens opportunities – USATODAY.com.

George Jones 1885The “End of summer…” in that headline link might hint that I’m not keeping up with the news. But I just stumbled on USA Today founder Al Neuharth’s column about newspaper history anniversaries while searching for something else and decided to add it to my media-history bookmark collection.

In the process, I noticed a forgotten man — the gent on the right.

I had forgotten him myself, but USAToday.com had remembered him with a link — very badly.

Despite what USA Today might have led you to believe, the man in question was never a country singer married to Tammy Wynette, and did not have hits like “Why, Baby, Why?” and “He Just Stopped Lovin’ Her Today.” He was the first  publisher of The New York Times.

When I think of  the founders of The New York Times, I think of Adolph S. Ochs, the one-time-Tennessean who set its “All the news that’s fit to print” agenda when he bought the struggling paper in 1896, and of Henry Raymond, a former star reporter for Horace Greeley‘s Tribune who was the first editor of the Times in 1851.

But until I saw Neuharth’s column, I had forgotten that Raymond had a partner named George Jones, a former banker turned publisher, who carried on long after Raymond’s death. I pulled down my copy of Meyer Berger’s history of the Times to refresh my memory, and popped over to Wikipedia for a picture.

It was nice of former USA Today publisher Neuharth to remember Mr. Jones, and I’m sure he wasn’t the one who placed that hyperlink to the wrong George Jones.

In fact, I don’t think any human did. My guess is that the link was added by something like a Perl or Python computer script in the USAToday.com content management system, programmed to match up a database list of “famous people” archive pages with names in the news. Result: Wrong George. The fact that the mistaken link has been there for six months doesn’t give me great feelings about the paper’s quality control.

My advice to online news publishers:

  • Useful hyperlinks are part of any online story.
  • Don’t leave them to idiots.
  • Computer programs are idiots, unless you spend IBM-style Jeopardy-beating millions of dollars on them.
  • But don’t. It would be better to spend the millions on a new generation of young fact-checkers and editors. You might start the careers of some future Henry Raymonds… or Al Neuharths.

Just in case you think that single computer-generated off-base hyperlink is the only problem, here are the “You might also be interested in…” headlines USAToday.com added to the end of that newspaper-history story for me:

Actually, I’d rather read about George Jones. Either one of them.


Sidebar: Speaking of Horace Greeley… I’ve been running into him a lot recently.

Considering the future of the Mag-App-Book

Khoi Vinh (subtraction.com), former design director at  The New York Times, offered some design-inspired thoughts the other day on “why most of the current crop of iPad magazine apps have dim prospects for long-term success,” which has prompted dozens of intelligent comments and a follow-up post: My-ipad-magazine-stand and more-on-ipad-magazines.

The combination sent me looking for something I’d read by Bob Stein a while ago,  The future of the app,  and an interview he did on NPR’s On The Media.

Stein’s Voyager company was creating innovative e-books and before that video discs back before the Web was spun. Some of them were so good, I’m thinking of buying an old computer that can still play them.  … which has me worried about the portability, searchability, longevity, archivability and general persistence of material created in the form of “apps” for particular computer, tablet or smartphone hardware.

I suspect folks like Bob Stein and Khoi Vinh are thinking about those issues, too… so I’m posting this here as a reminder to dip back into those discussions at their blog sites more often.

Online magazine or app publishing systems mentioned in the discussion, and related links:

Footnote: Unrelated, but interesting — The Observer on Khoi Vinh’s departure from the Times.

Related: Recent Chronicle of Higher Education article on Michael J. Bugeja and Daniela V. Dimitrova’s Vanishing Act: The Erosion of Online Footnotes and Implications for Scholarship in the Digital Age, lamenting the way redesigns and e-comings-and-goings kill links, even on the open Web. (We were on a panel discussion of related issues at AEJMC six years ago.)

Telecommuting from the Blueridge to the Rockies

I couldn’t go to the AEJMC convention in Denver this week, but I feel like I’m halfway there, following Twitter feeds and other online activities…

I’ve been updating the Newspaper Division’s blog with whatever I find online that might interest its members…

I’m still waiting to hear whether the “Newspaper Division” is still that, or has added “and Online Journalism” to its name, or named a committee to write a clarifying “statement of purpose” for one of AEJMC’s oldest and largest groups… and, come to think of it, to find out whether I’ve been re-elected its Web editor despite my perennial inability to get to the conventions.

Meanwhile, I keep thinking of an Eddie from Ohio song, with this lyric

you think you’ll find some mountains
in western colorado
fifty weeks of snowy peaks
is where you’re gonna be
but babe the rocky mountains are gradually eroding
the hills of coors are nothing more
than blue ridge wannabes…

Corporate vision or hubbed myopia?

http://www.editorandpublisher.com/Headlines/gannett-rolls-out-cci-newsgate-creates-page-production-hubs-61977-.aspx

You can’t buy out of town newspapers much anymore, so folks may not notice whether a visual homoginization  is the result of Gannett’s new “national page production network.”

In 10 years, will formerly great regional dailies be little more than a “local/state” sheet wrapping a copy of Gannett’s USA Today in a “hyperlocal” sheep’s clothing of reader blogs and snapshots?

Compare the TED video by a European newspaper designer on the video page of this blog. While you’re at it, watch the Onion piece on newspaper loons, too.

Tell Clyde I’m on the road to Floyd with a Droid

It was a tough decision, but having an excuse to write that headline made it all worthwhile.

My first “smartphone” was a Handspring Treo 180, almost 10 years ago. When I moved to Knoxville a few years later, the lack of T-Mobile service disabled most of the smartness, so I regressed to a Palm TX paired to a Cingular Razr Bluetooth phone, a semi-smart setup.

Last weekend, I wrestled the “iPhone vs. Droid” decision to a conclusion. With a Droid, I get Floyd: Verizon covers the neighboring county, AT&T doesn’t, and Floyd has some of my favorite folks and music stops on the crooked road. (I made the decision despite this horrible Droid website.)

Now I just have to convince my friend Clyde that I ordered the new smartphone (smart new phone?) before reading his blog saying that news folks should get smartphone-savvy right away. “Honest, Clyde, I got the Droid because of Floyd” sounds like one of those 1940s novelty songs.

Maybe I’ll get an iPad next month.

Anyhow, I’ll point AEJMC Newspaper readers to Clyde Bentley at the University of Missouri for a timeline for “Mobile Newspaper Success”…  The road to 2013: A timeline for newspapers.

Responding to a Gartner Research study that forecast  mobile devices would  replace PCs in Web access by 2013, Bentley built a timeline from the endpoint to the present.

If you’re a “key editor” at a newspaper, you should get a smartphone this month, or you’re already playing catch-up.

By August-September, Clyde says, newspapers should be training their news and ad staff on “mobile potential,” if they want to stay on track with the Gartner deadline. Within a year, mobile reporters should be producing niche-market features for mobile customers. Clyde’s examples: “Smoke-break wraps, during-game scores, pre-commute weather.”

He doesn’t mention one  crossover: Twitter (or Facebook status updates), whether Twitter’s  140-character limit is really enough for a “nugget of news” or not. Newspapers, broadcasters and online-only newsies are already tweeting away to anyone with a smartphone Twitter app, including Clyde’s own blog. So obvious it went without saying, I guess.

(I’m @bobstep on Twitter.)

(Note: If anyone from Verizon offers me a “referrer” bonus check for the slogan “Get Floyd with a Droid,” I’ll take it.)

The Wired Tablet App

Wired and other CondeNast magazines are headed for the iPad. Here’s a video intro.

more about “The Wired Tablet App “, posted with vodpod

As a subscriber to Wired from Vol.1 No.1, this new iPadded edition reminded me of the classic e-zine Suck.com’s instructions for coping with the old dead-tree and advertising-bloated edition, c. 1995:

How to read Wired Magazine

Footnote: I’m not the only nostalgic Wired (and Suck.com) reader.

Additional: Can Apple’s iPad Save the Media?

Although things could change on this front as more periodical publishers launch issues they’ve been preparing for the iPad, Apple’s demonstration of the New York Times on the iPad left a lot to be desired.

Update on Multimedia Journalism Bootcamp in Nashville

Nice new promotional video… I attended last summer’s version of this workshop; it was terrific and worth every penny. (And, no, my university didn’t contribute any of those 150,000 pennies. Hard times, and all that.)

Val Hoeppner’s Resources blog and Multimedia Toolbox document the equipment we used in the week-long, morning-to-night program. She includes tips and tutorials on the cameras, recorders and software.

Result: Here are two stories I co-produced, each with a different very talented classmate. Each was a day’s work, shooting and editing, after a day on how to use the equipment and software:

I’ve been trying to get the VodPod video player to embed those two stories, but it has problems, possibly because the page shows more than one video. However, it did capture this Animoto music video of our class at work in the lab last August. (About 1/4 of the way through, there are a few frames of evidence that my face did not “break the camera.”)

more about “FreedomForum Multimedia Bootcamp 09“, posted with vodpod

Note: Although I was personally counting my pennies (including travel to and from Nashville), the workshop was priced reasonably at $850 for a week of instruction and some meals, plus $71 per night to solo in an “extended stay” hotel room (with kitchen), which was more than I needed. On my next trip to Nashville, I found a lower rate at a Best  Western  even closer to the Seigenthaler Center.

The Bootcamp’s 12-hour-a-day schedule didn’t leave me time or energy to take in Nashville’s nightlife. so I stayed an extra day to go window shopping at George Gruhn’s.

The Future Journalist: Thoughts from Columbians

Under the heading The Future Journalist: Thoughts from Two Generations, Columbia Journalism School professor Sree Sreenivasan and student Vadim Lavrusik have recorded and posted a conversation at the Mashable group blog. I’m hoping it will reassure my students that their “older generation” journalism faculty are still pointing them toward useful things.

Sree is hardly an “older generation” journalist, if you think that means an ink-stained wretch in a green eyeshade and garters to keep his cuffs clean. I wonder if he ever had his byline set in hot type? In any case, he knows what he’s talking about.

Now Columbia’s dean of students, Sree has been on top of new media developments for the past 10 years, while Vadim has impressive credentials as an adopter of new social media tools — and both have self-promotional skills that it may take to get ahead in 21st century professional/citizen (and amateur/citizen) journalism.

Both also seem to agree on a big paragraph headed “The Fundamentals Are Critical”:

Despite the importance of technology, it’s the fundamentals of journalism that are still critical. The fundamentals include: great reporting and writing, journalistic ethics, specialization by topic or beat, investigative skills, news judgment. Also invaluable, critical thinking and critical reading…

I’ll stop quoting there and let you go read the whole page, watch the video, browse through the comments and add your own. Alas, my snowbound home computer won’t play the video, so I’ll save my own comments for a better connection.

I’m assuming their post will get a discussion growing, unless the Mashable readers with journalism interests are already worn out. Vadim’s essay on 8 Must-Have Traits for Tomorrow’s Journalist generated more than 70 comments at Mashable last month.